It’s been six(6) months since its initial release. How is Windows 10 shaping up?
My good buddy Ed Bott recently published an article on the state of Windows 10 from an industry perspective and it got me thinking of my OWN experience with Window s10, now that it’s been out for six or so months.
It’s not all sunshine and daisies. In fact, there’s a lot that needs to be fixed and changed. Here’s where I think the new OS stands at this point.
To say that the Windows 10 user interface is an improvement over Windows 8.x is a bit of an understatement. The UI is a huge improvement and one that nearly everyone who used Windows 8.x is glad to see. The Start Menu is back, and it’s something that nearly everyone is happy about. This single most, familiar UI tidbit is something that’s been around in computing since the release of Windows 95 – nearly 21years – and it’s something that nearly every consumer and corporate user has used and identified with as the beginning of their computing experience that they just can’t seem to give it up. Honestly, seeing as everyone nearly lost their minds when Microsoft replaced with the Start Screen, it’s amazing that people were able to use Windows 8.x at all. I mean, without a place to Start, how do you get work done?
The other, most noticeable change to the UI is the removal and death of Charms and the inclusion of the Action Center. The Charms were the UI element that you saw when you swiped in from the right edge of the screen with either your finger or with your mouse cursor. Those have been replaced by the Action Center, which is a general catch all for notifications and other items requiring… well, requiring user action.
The Action Center has been well received, in my opinion. It’s an easy tool to use, and gives you access to the system events you need to act on. Charms never did anything of value in my opinion, and were very confusing.
The thing that helped Windows 10 out the most is that, in all reality, its UI is more Windows 7 like. All of the ModernUI elements are gone. The ModernUI apps have been changed to Universal Apps and have a totally different look and feel to them. Isn’t it funny what a new coat of paint will do..?
The Update Mechanism
Microsoft seems hell bent on putting older versions of Windows out to pasture. It’s a problem they created for themselves with the support lifecycle of Windows XP and the absolute failure and public rejection of Windows Vista. An operating system version should never be in active support for 15 years.
As such, Windows 10 is on an auto update trajectory with destiny.
(Provided you have a legitimate, REAL copy…) If you run Windows 7, Microsoft is going to upgrade you to Windows 10 whether you want it or not… whether you like it or not. …) If you run Windows 8.x, Microsoft is going to upgrade you to Windows 10 whether you want it or not… whether you like it or not. There is no opt out. If you run an earlier version of Windows on your PC, other than a version of Windows 10, you’re going to eventually run Windows 10 on that PC.
Get over it. Stop complaining and just accept it. Apparently, there’s not much anyone can do. Microsoft is hell bent on getting all the world’s Windows users off of their older version of Windows and on to Windows 10… and apparently, they don’t care who they upset or anger in the process; and it doesn’t matter if you have that version of Windows running on hardware that the OEM won’t support with Windows 10.
In and of itself, upgrading and updating hardware that is on and supports Windows 10, is very easy. All the updates are pulled down in the background. You don’t even have to run Windows Update. It’s now a service that is run for you and all you have to do – at most – is simply restart your computer.
This is the cool part of the update mechanism. In fact, you don’t even have to restart your PC. Windows will do it for you and then apply all of the outstanding updates it has downloaded.
It’s the most hassle free way to update Windows… provided you actually want or are really able to run Windows 10.
I have yet to have Windows 8.x’s or Windows 10’s Recovery mode/ partition – whatever you want to call it – work correctly for me. And trust me…. this is definitely NOT a PEBKAC issue (Problem Exists Between Keyboard And Chair). I know my way around Windows; and honestly…
The feature just doesn’t work.
Most often, the feature doesn’t boot into Recovery Mode. It simply reboots the device, which totally defeats the purpose of the recovery partition in the first place.
When the recovery partition does do something else other than just simply reboot the device back into Windows 10, things usually go very, very wrong. Wrong to the tune of, “I need to download the recovery image from the internet, create a USB boot stick and try to run that to blow the device and start from factory fresh because my device is now hosed,” wrong.
And to be quite honest, I’ve had the same problem with the recovery partition in Windows 8.x AND in Windows 10. If you’ve been successful with a restore or complete wipe with the recovery partition running off the device’s internal drive and not off a USB stick, I’d love to talk to you about the experience and the process.
Microsoft’s Signature Hardware
I don’t want to over play this too much. I wanted to start off this section by saying something like, “wow! What a train wreck the Surface Pro and Surface Book are,” but that really isn’t very fair.
Make no mistake. Both of these devices have some very serious problems. Both of them have graphics driver issues that (at the very least) are at the root of the disappearing ink issue I’ve been barking about for the past year or more. The problem is so severe, that it’s also effecting the Surface Pro 3 (a problem, that I think many – including Microsoft – are overlooking).
The Surface Book as graphic driver issues but also has sleep and battery related problems. These problems are so severe that in many cases when users try to put the Surface Book to sleep, the device won’t sleep. When users try to sleep their computer and then put the device in a backpack or laptop bag, they often get what has been dubbed, “hot bag syndrome.” This is when the computer fails to sleep, continues to run, tries to “cool” itself with ever warming air (due to it being confined to the small, secure space of a laptop section in either a backpack or laptop bag), becomes overheated and the battery then quickly drops its charge to zero (0).
Having both the disappearing ink/ graphics driver issue along with these battery and sleep issues has made the Surface Book nearly unusable for many. Thankfully, I haven’t succumbed to any pressure related to making a Surface Book purchase. The device is simply too pricey to begin with. To have these simple usability issues on top of it all is nearly unforgivable in my opinion.
While this doesn’t make Windows 10 unusable, it kinda does make you wonder why Microsoft is having issues that it can’t seem to fix with its own, native hardware running its flagship OS, and many OEM’s are not.
I think I’ll just leave that one there to fester for a while…
I’m going to make this short. Windows 10 isn’t bad, but Microsoft has a ways to go yet, in my mind.
The UI is pretty good, and a much better improvement over Windows 10. I think Microsoft peaked in 2009 with Windows 7; but that’s my opinion. They haven’t always gotten things right, straight out of the gate. Heck, it took them three versions of Windows before they got THAT right (Windows 3.0 was the first big hit for Windows, and then it took three versions of Windows 3.x – Windows 3.0, 3.1 and Windows 3.11 – before they got THAT right.
Their update mechanism isn’t bad, but they need to stop forcing the upgrade on users who don’t want it or can’t run it because their hardware isn’t rated for it. If I don’t want Windows 10, please stop forcing it on me and my under rated hardware.
Their recovery mechanism needs a bit of work. I haven’t been able to make it work right. Unfortunately, with the way Windows problems work, in many ways its always been easier to rebuild a system rather than troubleshooting it. That isn’t always the case now.
Finally, Microsoft needs to stop screwing around and needs to fix the driver problems in their Signature hardware. If Microsoft can’t get this right, it’s hard to think that OEM’s and other PC manufacturers will.
Have you had issues with Windows 10? Are you satisfied with the way it runs on your upgraded or native PC? I’d love to hear how things are working for you. Why don’t you join me in the Discussion area below, and give me your thoughts on the matter.