I’ve been a fan of Japanese anime and the like since I was a kid. One series, however, Johnny Sakko and His Flying Robot was a favorite of mine when I was a kid, growing up in suburban Pittsburgh, PA for a couple of key reasons –
- It came on right after Ultraman
- Some of the tech it used – like a radio watch that allowed the story’s lead, Johnny, to control the actions of a towering, giant, defense robot – were pretty cool (especially for the late ’60’s and early ’70’s).
The concept behind the watch wasn’t completely new. Dick Tracy has been using a radio watch to communicate with his team since the comic series launched in October of 1931. However, it is a total geek-gasm, and it’s totally cool, especially since, we now possess THAT specific technology today.
In this light, I’ve approached my big writing project this summer – my Wearables Roundup – with a great deal of enthusiasm. I love gadgets, and I most especially love gadgets that I can take nearly everywhere with me. Here’s what we’ve got so far in the series:
- Microsoft Band Review – Completed (Part 1, Part 2)
- Fitbit Surge Review – Completed
- Apple Watch Review – In process (Latest article – Personal Setup of the Apple Watch
I’m still working through a lot of metal gyrations with the Apple Watch. There’s good and bad there, and it’s going to take a little bit of time to work through a supportable position on it. (Yes, it’s totally cool, but why is it totally cool; and what (if any) is a compelling reason to buy one…? I’m working on that…)
You may recall that I was – and in many ways still am – a big fan of the Pebble Steel. Has that changed? Does the Pebble Time improve on what Pebble and Pebble Steel introduced to the market? Let’s dig up our smartwatch review topics and find out.
In many ways, the Pebble Time should be considered the baseline of all smartwatch hardware. It could be because they were one of the first modern smartwatches to hit the market, filling a gap vacated by the exit of the Microsoft SPOT Watch, first introduced to a short, four year lifespan back in 2004. They continued to be supported three years beyond their death in 2008, finally losing support for their services on 2011-12-31. It could be because – that’s all that it really does – the baseline of what many smartwatches really are capable of…but I’m getting ahead of myself.
The hardware for the Pebble Time has the following basic specifications:
- Dimensions: 40.5×37.5×9.5 mm
- Weight: 42.5g (1.5oz, with strap)
- Band: 22mm (compatible with all 22mm watch bands)
As you can see from the specs and from the pictures, below, this puts it in the same size category as the 38mm Apple Watch. The front casing has an Stainless Steel bezel, but don’t think that this device has a metal casing. It doesn’t, it has a plastic casing. The bezel is just that – a bezel, and while it may be made of Marine Grade Stainless Steel with PVD coating, it really looks more like anodized aluminum than Stainless. I don’t think it provides much protection for the device. It’s purely decoration only. However, it does have a nice matte finish and looks good. The watch body also has a thin, curved ergonomic profile, which is supposed to make it a more comfortable, long term wear than watches that don’t have the same type of bend.
The Time has a tough, 2.5D (Gorilla) glass crystal covering an always on, color e-paper display with LED backlight. The display is clearly readable in both indoor and outdoor lighting, and even though it’s always on, the device comes with a 7-day rated battery life. This improves on the Pebble and Pebble Steel which went about 5 or so days, depending on use. Seven solid days is pretty decent. So, high marks to Pebble on this feature. I’ll have more on this in the Battery Life section, below.
However, it’s not all sunshine and daisies for the display. The biggest problem with it, is that it’s difficult to read in low light situations. You’d think that the backlight would help here, but it doesn’t. The backlight tends to wash out the display, so it looks more white than anything else, which is unfortunate. Someone with not so great eyesight, like me, may have trouble reading it in low light situations, and that’s not good.
The Time also has a built in microphone for voice notes and quick replies, however, I don’t know how practical it is. Yeah, I know, the whole Dick Tracy/ Johnny Sakko thing of talking to your watch is kinda cool, but I haven’t had any real luck with that feature in any other setting other than a quiet room or office; and honestly, if those kinds of places are the only ones that’s any good in, then having a microphone on the Pebble Time is a waste of internal space.
Finally, the Pebble time has a vibrating motor for discreet alerts and alarms, which allow you to silently notify or wake yourself, and not anyone else. This is a great way of getting up in the morning without some ugly blaring, beeping noise going off in your ear, or the music on your clock radio sending you AND your cat to the ceiling because your kids are smart alecks and have turned the volume on it “all the way up to 11.” The Time is also water resistant to 30 meters, insuring that an inerrant swim or shower won’t ruin the watch by having it come in contact with water.
On paper, the Pebble Time really looks like a cool smartwatch. However, the hardware looks, well… campy, I guess is the best way to put it. The original Pebble wasn’t very professional looking and while competitors like the Microsoft Band (Part 1,Part 2) and the Fitbit Surge are total dork magnets, their somewhat less than high-dollar look and feel can be completely excused due to their heavy fitness tracking functionality.
Now, before everyone gets their compression pants in a knot, yes. I know that the Time can “do” fitness related stuff too. Yeah, but not really. As with the Pebble, Pebble Steel and now the Pebble Time, all Pebble smartwatches can “do” fitness tracking. However, they are completely dependent on your smartphone or other device to count steps, track progress, etc. What the watch can do is display data from your connected phone.
Yes, it has an accelerometer and a compass; but it doesn’t have an A/GPS receiver, so it can’t track your progress natively. If you forget your phone or leave it home when you go out on a run or walk, you’re not going to get any fitness data on your workout. The watch also doesn’t have any heat or heart rate sensors, so don’t look to it to keep track of any physical attributes when you work out either. The Time also doesn’t work with Google Fit, the Android answer to Apple Health (oh, and it doesn’t work with Apple Health, either…)
When you look at the device as a whole – plastic body and case, rubber/ silicone band, I can’t help but be a bit disappointed. Maybe it’s because I’m also wearing the Apple Watch, and because I’ve also got an Olio Model One coming. I don’t know. Honestly, both the Microsoft Band and the Fitbit Surge aren’t “high end” devices.so I know I’m not turning into a watch snob or anything; but I can’t help but be disappointed.
Wearability and Usability
So what is the Pebble Time like to wear and how usable is it?
Like the Fluoroelastomer band on the Apple Watch, the silicone band on the Pebble Time is just as comfortable and just as soft and silky feeling. However, in long term wear, I had issues with it creating dry patches on my skin. I was not pleased with that at all. The band simply doesn’t breathe very well, and it’s not surprising. It is, after all… a silicone band.
The curved hardware casing of the watch ads a level of comfort… I think. Honestly, it’s hard to tell, as with a device this small and thin, it’s difficult to know if a curved case vs. a standard shaped case – i.e. like any other watch – makes any real or noticeable difference. Honestly, I can’t tell; but it is at least nice to know that the feature is there.
Like its predecessors, the Pebble Time gets Notifications right.
Notifications are configurable on your phone and alert you when needed. With the Time’s Timeline feature, you can even review them as part of your Present or Past Timelines. The only caution I have here is that you take the time to configure your notifications correctly so that you don’t get bombarded by them . The idea behind the Time – and all other smartwatches for that matter – is to make dealing with them easier and less intrusive. If you’re constantly checking your watch because you have your Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, Snapchat, etc. social networking accounts dinging your watch, then you likely haven’t improved on anything and have overloaded your ability to effectively and discretely address notifications with the Time (or, again, any other smartwatch).
I do NOT like how the Time interfaces with my iPhone.
The Pebble Time connects to my iPhone 6 the same way my Pebble Steel does – with a regular Bluetooth partnership and then with a Bluetooth LE partnership. This type of relationship has proven to be problematic in the past. If the Bluetooth LE partnership doesn’t link up after pairing (and because the LE communication uses its own partnership vs sharing the main Bluetooth pairing, it often can), then you aren’t going to get notifications. This starts to become evident after things are “too quiet” on the notification front after a while.
I haven’t run into this yet on the Time, but it happens quite often with my Pebble Steel, and it’s very frustrating.
The Pebble Time has a Lithium-ion polymer battery that Pebble rates for up to seven (7) days of battery life. This is both good and bad. The good is obvious. The bad may seem silly, but you’ll get it once you hear it.
Seven days of battery life (I got about five and a half during this review, due largely, to all of the fiddling and playing I did) is awesome. I love not having to remember to charge my battery every night. It makes for a much more familiar watch wearing experience. The magnetic charging port on the Time has been moved to the back of the device as opposed to the side on the Pebble and Pebble Steel. The magnetic port on the Time is also supposed to support future smart accessories, that may be built into a watch strap (hence the move to the back of the watch).
I have no idea what those accessories may be or when they may be available, so at this point, I wouldn’t worry too much about them or how much they may cost. IF they show, they can be reviewed and commented on like any other smartwatch accessory for the Apple Watch (or other watch that may have available accessories…but right now, I can’t think of any others. Can you..??)
Software and Interfaces
At the end of the day, while having a nice bit of hardware on your wrist is nice, what’s going to make or break the device is the software that it uses on device and on your smartphone. Needless to say, yes… I have opinions on both the device software and the Pebble Time App.
At the end of the day, though, this winds up being nothing more than a shuffle of the cards and a coat of paint. That is to say, yes… I’m calling the interface a total dud. Let’s check out why…
First and foremost, let’s be clear – from a software perspective, the Pebble Time didn’t bring anything new to the table except its color, ePaper display.
Yes, I know it has a new software interface. However, the interface on the Time is really nothing more than a reorganization of the information Pebble has had on their watches from day one (except now color enabled), with a new coat of paint. Pebble Time now organizes your information into three different buckets Past (top, right, device-side button) Present (middle device-side button) and Future (bottom, right, device-side button). You can review all of your notifications via your Timeline and see what’s most important to you “right now” by simply sticking to the middle and/ or bottom right buttons. You can review anything you’ve missed by tapping the top right button.
The organization they’ve implemented isn’t a bad idea. In fact, it’s pretty cool; but tying it with the three right side, device buttons is very 2012; and with touch screens available on the Apple Watch and even the Microsoft Band, limiting how you’re reviewing notifications to actions and activities keyed off of buttons on the Time is (now) a bit clunky. A touch screen implementation with swipes and taps would have been much better; and better received, too.
Finally, and I can’t put it off any longer – ‘cuz this is the right place to mention it – the interface itself is horrible. The screens look as though they were painted by my 7 year old son. I am so upset about this, to the point where its infuriating.
Again, the word “campy,” comes to mind, and it’s such a shame. While I know that the Pebble Time is a budget oriented smartwatch, it doesn’t have to look budget oriented. I know there’s only so much you can do with a color ePaper display, but Pebble could have done so much more with the graphics and SDK to have the time present a more professional, much more mature interface. With items like the Apple Watch and the Olio Model One out there, a little more sophistication out of the Pebble Time couldn’t hurt, and would have been much welcomed.
The thing that bothers me the most about this, is that UI design choice “A” vs. UI design choice “B” doesn’t necessarily cost more. You still have to draft it all out, create the screens, review the designs, etc., and having a more sophisticated, more professional look couldn’t have been more costly during its initial development. The Time is a budget watch, yes, but it doesn’t have to look that way, does it?! I know I’ve repeated myself here, but I mean… COME ON, people!
The original monochrome UI elements on the Pebble and Pebble Steel looked better than this, I think. Unfortunately, the implementation of color into your UI can bring out its weaknesses as much as it can show its strengths. The design language needs to be changed here to allow for a more professional look and feel. It would be nice if Pebble provided that option to its users in a future firmware update.
Pebble Time App
I’ve found this to be yet another huge disappointment.
The new Pebble Time smartphone companion app is really nothing more than the ORIGINAL Pebble app with a new coat of paint to allow for apps with color screens to be offered. While I don’t think you can use the new app to connect to the original Pebble or Pebble Steel – you still need the original app for that – it’s clear that all of the familiar apps from the original monochrome store are offered and available for the Time.
New watch should have offered me a new companion app with a new UI and a new design and, as I mentioned above, a better app offering with much more professional graphics. I’ve got screen shots of the smartphone companion app below, and as you can see, and I think agree, this struck me as a “very familiar” (which isn’t necessarily bad) and “nothing special” experience (which isn’t good).
The new store and new watch do offer the opportunity to get a better set of watch faces, but as you notice by running through the store, many of them are really nothing more than the old monochrome faces, now colored for the new ePaper display. Again, a huge disappointment.
As with the original Pebble and Pebble Steel, the Pebble Time works with both iOS (running iOS 8 and higher) and Android (running 4.0 ICS and higher) smartphones. So this is about as cross platform a smartwatch offering as you can get.
The only downside to all of this is that if you really want to track any fitness info with the Time, you’re going to need a third party fitness tracker like the Misfit or Jawbone (recommended by Pebble) in order to do it. Additional language and international character support for the Time is said to be coming soon.
Problems and Issues
I think I’ve covered most the of the issues that I’ve bumped into with the Pebble Time in other sections. I won’t go over them again here.
The biggest thing that you do need to be aware of if you’re upgrading to the Time from either the Pebble or Pebble Steel is that the bands are not interchangeable or reusable on the new watch. Any favorite band styles will need to be repurchased for use with the Time. However, since the time uses a standard 22mm band, they shouldn’t be too difficult to find or replace.
The biggest problem that I have with the Pebble Time is that the device is a huge disappointment to me. It’s not a bad device, per se. There just isn’t anything here that would make me really WANT to upgrade from my Pebble Steel to the time – except its color ePaper display – and that certainly isn’t worth the cost of the new watch. In my opinion, the original Pebble Steel should have been introduced with a color display. It would have made much more sense, and honestly, would have totally negated the introduction or release of the Pebble Time. Perhaps we would have gotten something different or better if it had.
The Pebble Time should be considered the base line for any smartwatch. It has all of the basic functionality that would be considered mandatory in a smartwatch. The absence of any kind of native fitness tracking in the actual device, however, is a huge hole, and one that will really make individuals looking for a smartwatch stop and consider or reconsider its purchase. Other devices exist for about or near the same cost that include the fitness stuff, and as such kinda make the Pebble Time a bit irrelevant even before it had a chance to make any kind of impact on the market.
The Pebble Time is currently available for pre-order (as of this writing) and will cost $199.99.